Merger Arbitrage: 12% Upside (at 17p/share)
Here’s another junior mining buyout that looks highly likely to close. The consideration is all-cash, the spread sits at 12%. With closing expected in 6 months, the IRR is pretty decent.
Atlantic Lithium is advancing the Ewoyaa lithium project in Ghana. The company has agreed to be acquired by Zhejiang Huayou Cobalt, an $18bn market-cap Chinese battery materials manufacturer. The consideration is US$0.25486/share in cash (equivalent to 19p/share). The company’s largest shareholder, controlling a 26.4% stake, has already committed to supporting the deal. With the directors and two other major holders also virtually guaranteed to follow suit, upfront support effectively sits at 33%. Shareholder vote is set for November and closing is expected in December.
The timeline is a bit stretched, likely due to the regulatory approval processes in China and Ghana, alongside the required nod from Australia’s Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB). That said, neither jurisdiction is expected to throw up any major roadblocks. Atlantic’s assets are located in Africa, and the buyer is Chinese company. Beijing has long maintained a rock-solid relationship with Ghana, and is Ghana’s largest trading partner. This dynamic in the mining space has even been institutionalized: the China-Ghana Mining Association was officially launched last year with the mandate to deepen cooperation across the sector. Chinese buyers have been aggressively acquiring major gold assets across the country for a while.
The Ewoyaa lithium project is an important asset for Ghana, slated to become the country’s first-ever lithium mine. However, the development of the mine has been sluggish so far, stuck for a long time in regulatory bottlenecks. The definitive feasibility study was completed in 2023, but then it took two and a half years to get the mining lease through the Ghanaian parliament. That ratification finally came through this March, two years behind the initial 2024 timeline, opening the door for full project financing and the final investment decision.
But then the financing of the mine development seems to have become another holdup. Atlantic’s joint venture partner, Elevra Lithium (North American lithium producer with a US$2.5bn market cap), has basically refused to continue funding the project. Elevra earned its current 22.5% project interest by bankrolling the exploration stage, and had the right to raise its interest to 50% by providing another $70m. Elevra also holds half the seats on the project’s technical committee, which decides the development path. The JV partner rejected Atlantic’s recent development proposals (which likely included further financing from Elevra), stating that Ewoyaa now “sits lower on its list of priorities for capital deployment.”
Elevra is now selling its project interest and all corresponding rights to the same buyer, Zheijiang Huayou. This transaction is not conditioned on the buyout of Atlantic Lithium, but will also need regulatory approval. A deep-pocketed Chinese sponsor should finally help to jumpstart the development.
Interestingly, last year, when lithium prices were at lows, Atlantic’s CEO threatened to close the development, demanding tax and royalty concessions from Ghana, saying the mine had become uneconomical and “nobody is going to put their money in that.” While some of the concessions were granted and lithium prices have since rebounded, I wouldn’t be surprised if this episode, alongside the terrible development pace, contributed to Elevra’s exit. Meanwhile, Chinese buyers are often less price sensitive when it comes to critical material acquisitions, and have a strong track record of operating in Africa and Ghana.
All of this just to drive home the point that I think Zheijiang Huayou will not walk away and that regulatory approval won’t be an issue here.
As for the shareholder approval, the consent looks fairly certain. The largest shareholder, Assore, which owns 26.4%, has given its support. Assore tried to buy Atlantic Lithium for 33p/share back in 2023, but the offer was rejected. The fact that it is now willing to sell at a substantially lower price speaks for itself. Clearly, the project’s long-term backers are not happy with where things stand.
Atlantic Lithium’s directors own 1.8%, Elevra owns 4%, and Ghana’s sovereign minerals fund holds another 2.4%. Altogether, that’s a 33% in support. The deal requires 75% approval of votes cast and a 50% headcount majority of shareholders present and voting. There are no other major holders, so it’s very unlikely this buyout gets blocked.
There is some noise on retail investor forums. One HotCopper member claims to lead a group representing over 4% of the shares that plans to vote against the transaction. Aside from this anecdotal detail, I think this forum message sums up the situation pretty well:
Blocking this takeover is probably worse for shareholders than letting it proceed. Look at the lack of progress over the years. Like many have already said on this forum. This is Africa and the only people that seem to be able to get things done in Africa are the Chinese.
The downside to pre-announcement levels is 12%. However, the actual loss if the current deal breaks could be larger. The stock ran up right before the announcement of the buyout offer. It’s not clear whether the price surge was due to the anticipated Parliament ratification of the mine or some leaks around the bid. The stock has been trading at 14.5p-17p/share since early February and at 10-12p/ prior to that.
By the way, Atlantic is dual-listed, with far more liquid trading on the London’s AIM market compared to Australian stock exchange (ticker A11.AX).
The parties have received FIRB approval. The Chinese and Ghanaian regulatory approvals remain outstanding, but seem likely to pass. Shareholder approval is practically guaranteed given the support from the largest shareholder. The spread remains wide at 26%.
The scheme meeting is expected in November, with closing expected by year-end.
https://www.investegate.co.uk/announcement/rns/atlantic-lithium-limited-npv-di—all/scheme-update-firb-approval-received/9776163
The spread has widened even further, to 40%, with no news or updates. The market clearly has little faith that Ghanaian regulatory approval will come through. I still find it difficult to see the deal being blocked.
Ghanaian regulators have approved Zhejiang Huayou’s acquisition of a 22.5% stake in the Ewoyaa lithium project. The deal was completed yesterday. Zhejiang has also assumed responsibility for ~US$66m of the project’s development costs. Once that funding is complete, Huayou will receive a further 27.5% take, taking its total interest to 50%.
This is great news for ALL. Having approved Zhejiang’s entry into Ewoyaa, Ghanaian regulators are very unlikely to object to Zhejiang’s takeover of ALL. The arb spread narrowed from 40% to 20% on the news.
It’s puzzling why the spread remains so wide. Ghanaian reg risk is now largely gone, and Zhejiang has confirmed it is still interested in the project. One possible concern is that lithium prices have dropped significantly since the buyout was announced, which could lead to a price cut for ALL. However, Chinese buyers tend to care more about locking in control of critical minerals than about short-term price swings (of a very volatile commodity), and probably would not want to blow up the deal by trying to lower the offer.
https://www.investegate.co.uk/announcement/rns/atlantic-lithium-limited-npv-di—all/completion-of-novation-agreement/9840002
Do we have an estimated closing date on this? I understand its slightly different for every case (as they always are).
1) Ghanian regulators have approved the acquisition and 2) court hearing on 11/5 is expected to go smoothly with shareholder approval. Perhaps the spread exists because there’s some uncertainty with the approval base. What is usually the timeline after these milestones are hit?
Shareholder meetings are usually scheduled a few weeks after the first court hearing, so this one should take place in the second half of November. Closing typically comes a few days to a few weeks after approval. A Ghanaian tax ruling is also still needed, and it is hard to say whether that could cause delays. So far, however, nothing suggests closing will be pushed beyond the initially expected December deadline.
The shareholder meeting has been set for December 14. The expected closing timeline has slipped slightly from December to mid-January. The spread is now at 15%.
https://www.investegate.co.uk/announcement/rns/atlantic-lithium-limited-npv-di—all/court-approves-convening-of-scheme-meeting/9860245